Monday, January 12, 2009

Recessions and voting behaviour

Paulie links to Matthew Taylor who argues that since the average family will actually be better off in 2009, that this might be bad news for the Conservatives.

I think he's wrong and by extension it might serve as a refutation of 'rational choice' models of voting behaviour that assume people vote according to their own material self-interest?

There is nothing unusual about the majority actually being better-off in recessions. Owners of businesses find their profits squeezed and some fold altogether. And it goes without saying that for those losing their jobs, recessions and depressions are a personal disaster. But most people neither own businesses nor lose their jobs and for these the general pattern is for them to see their disposable incomes rise.

What we are seeing now has conformed to a familiar pattern. Subsiding inflation - indeed the threat of deflation - means cheaper money, which in turn means existing loans are cheaper to pay off. And with actual deflation, people on fixed incomes actually see their real incomes rise. This formed part of Keynes' critique of the classical notion that labour markets 'clear'. "This is all very well in a world without institutions", he said (I'm paraphrasing from memory - I'm a lazy bastard - you know the drill by now), "but life ain't like that. In the real world, wages are 'sticky' downwards". In real terms, labour becomes more expensive so firms economise. This generally is good for people who remain in work - but obviously sucks for people losing their jobs.

But the majority that remain in work and who are almost always better off have never, to my knowledge, rewarded a government for this. It might not be quite the opposite of selfishness: perhaps the more fortunate voter thinks, "Shit, I could be next for the dole". Or perhaps they are adversely affected personally by the social costs of higher unemployment. But for whatever reason, the perception that a government has presided over economic failure doesn't bode well for them at the ballot box - regardless of the fact that a majority of the voters might actually be better off.

On a related point, I'm concerned that the government's policies might not work because of the way people's expectations of the future tend to take hold. I feel this myself. Twice in my incompetent life I've made sensible financial decisions - rare things for me. Got myself a fixed-rate thingy just before interest rates started to rise - then got myself a variable one just before they started to fall. I wouldn't like to tell any London readers how cheap my mortgage is right now because they would probably cry. But the thing is, I'm not thinking, "Hooray - think I'll go out spending for Queen and country". I'm thinking, "Better not get used to this - this ain't going to last".

Thursday, January 08, 2009

Death in Gaza and the character of Hamas

I'm not keen to add to the internet sewer on this subject so I'll be brief: the latter simply cannot be held to justify the former.

Endlessly repeating that Hamas are constitutionally committed to the destruction of the state of Israel simply isn't good enough. Notions of proportionality cannot be dismissed so easily because there is a difference between intention and capability.

In this context, those who impute great importance to what a bunch of fuck-nuggets in Dublin choose to do in their obviously copious free-time might want to ask themselves whether they haven't lost a sense of, well, proportion.

Monday, December 29, 2008

Against pontificating priests

I'm generally uninterested in the theological opinions of politicians and in the political opinions of theologians because apart from a general view on my part that religion and the state should be kept separate - both of these are generally characterised by an ignorance of the matters on which they speak.

But what with the Anglican church being our oldest nationalised industry, I suppose a certain overlap is inevitable. In these circumstances, I know who's opinion I'd rather hear. Gordon Brown knows more about their subject than these pontificating priests know about his. You'd think they might recognise this and hold their counsel but - and I'm sure I'm not alone in noticing this - Christians, by and large, don't do humility anymore.

Clerics in Germany, or one of them at least, blamed the banks - or one of them at least. Ours, on the other hand, blamed individuals and by extension the government for failing to restrain the greedy plebs:
"The Rt Rev Stephen Lowe, the Church's Bishop for Urban Life and Faith, said he feared Britain would simply return to a "financial system based on indebtedness" after the current crisis.

"The government isn't telling people who are already deep in debt to stop overextending themselves, but instead is urging us to spend more," he said.

"That is morally suspect and morally feeble. It is unfair and irresponsible of the government to put pressure on the public to spend in order to revive the economy.""
A financial system based on indebtedness, eh? How does he think banks make their money? And how does he think most of us who don't get houses with our jobs manage to get a roof over our heads, if not by borrowing? It should go without saying that this particular cleric has yet to graduate to the kindergarten of economic history.

They could, I suppose, have made more circumscribed criticism of the government - because for this there is, I would concede, plenty of scope. But there's one reason why they couldn't; it would deprive them of the room they need for moral posturing - which is, after all, their stock in trade. And there's anther reason why they shouldn't; it would be inappropriate, taking sides in party politics. But they've already done this...
"The Rt Rev Graham Dow, the Bishop of Carlisle, said: "I agree with the Conservatives that the breakdown of the family is a crucial element in the difficulties of our present society."
It's perhaps unfair to suggest that the partisan comments of the Rev Dow are representative of all of our seasonal preaching pontiffs but in general I really have to laugh when people try and suggest that the church ever attacks the government from the left. They attack this government, any government, from the standpoint of the past - something that should be remembered by anyone finding anything 'progressive' about the pronouncements of pontificating priests.

Update: Seems the Rev Dow has form. From Don in the comments I learn he's not merely a meddling reactionary - but a bat-shit crazy meddling reactionary. He thinks Gordon Brown's government is the incarnation of the anti-Christ and that floods are a judgment from God for tolerating homosexuals.

The latter view is surprisingly popular amongst fundamentalists clerics of all hues but it doesn't stand up to much scrutiny, does it? Because if that were the case, Brighton would be like Atlantis by now.*

*Stolen from here.

Sunday, December 21, 2008

Enough of this shit...

For 2008.

Merry Christmas and aura best for the New Year when it comes. x

Friday, December 19, 2008

Should have been from the Department of the Bleeding Obvious...

Hats. I don't do hats. As well as reducing my face to imbecility, they get goddam itchy after a while - so I don't wear 'em.

But don't dare complain of being cold if you don't have a woolly bunnet on because you always get someone saying, "Well, you should wear a hat - don't you know you lose 40% of your body heat through your head?"

I've always though this was crap - and I never understood why people believed this counterintuitive nonsense.

Today I stand hatless and vindicated by science.

Blog Archive