Peter Riddell thinks not. For one, he argues, it wasn't a premeditated confrontation with sections of the party that were perceived to represent unelectability in the way Blair's move to scrap clause 4 obviously was.
The other is that this is actually an issue of substance. Grammar schools actually exist - and many Tories would like to see more.
Clause 4, in contrast, was purely symbolic: only a fantasist could believe the party's retention of this arcane document meant a future Labour administration would be committed to the nationalisation of the means of production, distribution and exchange.
He's right about this, I think - as is Steve Richards, who points out that the advocates of grammars in the Tory party far outweigh those in the Labour party who ever seriously believed Clause 4 represented a template for a future government.
Yet it's more like Clause 4 than either of these allow. For while Cameron may not have deliberately chosen this as an issue on which to confront his party, this is what it has become nevertheless. And where the analogy holds is that while it may not be exactly essential, it would be nevertheless beneficial for Cameron to be seen to defeat the section within his own party that is rooted in the past.
The other reason is that while grammar schools do indeed exist, there are after all only 164 of them in the country: the idea that a future Tory government would extend the selection principle such as it operates in Buckinghamshire to the entire country really is a fantasy. Not one quite on the Arthur Scargill scale of delusion - but a fantasy nonetheless.
"It has been the misfortune of this age, that everything is to be discussed, as if the constitution of our country were to be always a subject rather of altercation than enjoyment." - Edmund Burke anticipates the Neverendum
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2007
(212)
-
▼
May
(40)
- The Cardinal, abortion and the nationalists
- On Jacobins and theocrats: an open email to Christ...
- Blair and Brown snub for the First Minister
- Gordon Brown's God
- Grass thy neighbour
- Homeopathy and open-mindedness
- Gordon Brown for Britain
- Kaletsky on grammars
- The war against bullshit
- Keeping the faith schools
- David Cameron and grammars: the Tories' clause 4?
- Goddam workplace notices
- Health insurance
- Radiation-proof pants
- Against monism: the language of rights and its lim...
- Grammars: the assumption of success?
- Political rhetoric annoyances #2
- Political rhetoric annoyances
- Alex Salmond installed as first minister
- Pure quality, by the way
- Churches, cults and paranoia
- Reality trumps dystopian sci-fi (again)
- An argument for atheism
- Prohibition arguments
- Thought for today
- The truimph of the bullshit generation
- Blair's legacy
- Teachers in 'web bullying' call
- Coalition talks
- Ballot confusion: for majoritarianism?
- Against referenda
- Buckfast
- Losing gracelessly
- Liveblogging the election
- Teaching happiness
- People losing their damn minds #20
- Against the assumption of nationalism
- Holyrood election is moderately interesting shock
- For Unionism
- The end of the long goodbye
-
▼
May
(40)
Details
Media
British and Scottish Social
Elections and Voters
Quilted blogroll
- A Cloud in Trousers
- Bad Conscience
- Bloggers4Labour
- Butterflies and Wheels
- Chase me ladies, I'm in the Cavalry
- Christopher Hitchens
- Dave Hill
- Dave Osler
- EngageOnline
- Excuse me while I step outside
- Fat Man on a Keyboard
- Flying Rodent
- Freemania
- George Szirtes
- Labour and Capital
- Martin in the margins
- Mick Hartley
- Never Trust a Hippy
- Nick Cohen
- Normblog
- Obcene Desserts
- Olly's Onions
- Pickled Politics
- Rosie Bell
- Rullsenberg Rules
- Shiraz Socialist
- Simply Jews
- Slugger O'Toole
- Stumbling and Mumbling
- The gaping silence
- We'll Get it Right Next Time
- Whitehall 1212
Blogroll with aloe vera
British and Scottish Political
Miscellaneous International
- Amnesty International
- China links
- China Support Network
- CIA factbook
- Democracy Now
- Europa - EU Online
- Human Rights in China
- Human Rights Watch
- International Labour Organization
- Labour Friends of Iraq
- South Africa links
- Statistical Abstract of the US
- Tibet Administration in Exile
- US Elections Stats
- Whitehouse Homepage
No comments:
Post a Comment